Our Menu
Ice Cream • Specialty Items • Seasonal items • Ice Cream Cakes
Always Available
Classic Flavors
These five flavors are our year-round foundation – expect them every visit.
Chairperson of the Board
Blueberry Cheesecake (Nut-free)
Our signature cream cheese-based ice cream includes layers of graham crackers and blueberry jam.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Andy Griffith
Vanilla Bean (GF • Nut-free)
Nothing is more vanilla than Andy Griffith. We use pastured milk and cream from Saratoga Springs to create a sweet, creamy vanilla sensation.
Contains: Dairy, Egg
Nunu’s Peach Cobbler
Peach Cobbler (Nut-free)
Pureed peaches with a dash of cinnamon and homemade crisp for a cobbler crunch, named after Nunu, Petrushka’s sister.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Hello, New World
Cookies & Caramel (Nut-free)
Caramel ice cream, vanilla wafers, oreo cookies, and caramel swirls.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Sweet Socialism
Dark Chocolate Sorbet (GF • Vegan • Nut-free)
Single-estate dark chocolate from Madagascar, this decadent, rich sorbet often mistaken for ice cream because of its creamy, milky texture.
Contains: No allergens
Rotating • Small Batch
Fall Flavors
These flavors change with the season, inspired by Harlem, our neighbors, and the cultures we represent. Not all flavors are available every day and at each store.
A$AP Road
Rocky Road
Always representing Harlem, this Flacko-inspired Rocky Road ice cream is a spin on the classic flavor. It includes milk chocolate with toasted hazelnut, marshmallow, oreo cookies, and graham crackers. Having introduced this flavor to our dipping case at the beginning of 2020, it has become a favorite among first time and regular customers.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Tree Nuts
Goddess Pomona
Apple Cider
Nothing says fall like apples. Maybe you wait for the apple cider donuts at your local farmer’s market or you buy a bushel on your weekend visit to your nearest apple orchard. Our Goddess Pomona hits all your fall apple cravings. Made with apple cider and a vegan caramel swirl, this flavor is sure to delight everyone, especially because it’s dairy-free.
Contains: Coconut
I Live It, How I Get It
Ooey Gooey Butter Cake & Lemon Meringue
With a cream cheese ice cream base, brown butter cake, and lemon curd swiss meringue folded in, this ice cream has the perfect balance of sweet and tart and is sure to be your next favorite Sugar Hill Creamery flavor.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Larry Wilcox
Mint Chip
When we make each of our flavors we believe in using real ingredients, not imitations. The Larry Wilcox is no exception. The coolness of each spoonful comes from the actual mint leaf that we incorporate in the base. We fold in shards of chocolate for the chip. Customers have raved that our mint chip is the real deal and does not taste like toothpaste. If mint chip ice cream is your thing, it will be hard to go back to whatever brand you were eating before ours.
Contains: Dairy
Miss Lolly’s Butter Cake
Butter Pecan Ice Cream with Butter Cake
A classic butter pecan ice cream brought into the 21st century, inspired by Miss Lolly’s Kitchen and paired with rich, straightforward butter cake. Miss Lolly was the iconic Harlemite Bevy Smith’s mother. She raised three children with her husband in Harlem and was known for elaborate Sunday dinners, often featuring multiple desserts. Butter pecan was Miss Lolly’s favorite ice cream flavor, while butter cake is one of Bevy Smith’s favorite desserts. Together, they blend two delicious desserts into one.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Tree-Nuts
Fallout
Walnut Cream, Pumpkin Bread
Toasted walnuts for 48 hours, then adds walnut-pumpkin bread and a bright wild blueberry apple jam. Both are spiced with berbere, a smoky Ethiopian spice blend, for an original ice cream that's nutty, buttery, and spicy.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Tree-Nuts
Tell It To The Block
Cinnamon & Hot Honey Ice Cream
At Sugar Hill Creamery, we love cinnamon ice cream but we thought the flavor needed a bit of kick. We make honeycomb candy with New York’s favorite Mike’s Hot Honey folded in for a sweet spicy treat.
Contains: Dairy, Egg
The Unicorn
Birthday Cake
This birthday cake ice cream has a color palette to make any child dream of unicorns. We add homemade gluten-free vanilla cake with a chromatic punch, royal frosting, and rainbow sprinkles to our vanilla base to inspire a cake and ice cream dream.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Year-Round
Specialty Items
More than a scoop - our in-house specialties are built around the same flavors you love. Customize each with the flavors we’re scooping.
Brownie Sundae
Two scoops of ice cream topped with homemade brownies, chocolate or caramel sauce, and whipped cream. Then, we repeat.
Ice Cream Sandwich
Build an ice cream sandwich with our housemade chocolate chip cookies and your choice of ice cream.
Ice Cream Float
Your choice of ice cream paired with your choice of Jarritos Tamarind or Mandarin soda, Root Beer, or Ginger Beer.
Malted Milkshake
Your choice of two scoops of ice cream with or without malt powder.
Limited • While in Season
Seasonal Items
We follow the seasons — warm drinks, baked goods, and limited-run items that make every visit feel different.
Haitian Campfire
Haitian Hot Chocolate Custard Tart with Torched Marshmallow Fluff - Fall/Winter (Nut-free)
Custard tart made with a crème brûlée filling in a handmade graham cracker crust, served à la mode with our signature Haitian Hot Chocolate Ice Cream and dollop of toasted marshmallow fluff.
Contains: Dairy, Egg
The Gasby
Peach Cobbler a la mode Cinnamon Ice cream - Fall/Winter (Nut-free)
Made as an homage to one of our founder's godmother, The Gasby is a housemade peach cobbler with bourbon-roasted peaches spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and bright lemon zest and served warm with a scoop of cinnamon ice cream.
Contains: Gluten, Alcohol
Ice Cream Hot Chocolate
Available in the Fall/Winter
Handmade, small-batch hot chocolate with our signature vanilla ice cream, 64% Guayaquil chocolate, and house-made torched marshmallow fluff.
Contains: Dairy, Egg
DIY Hot Chocolate Kit
Available in the Fall/Winter
One pint of Andy Griffith vanilla bean ice cream, a bag of hot chocolate mix and a homemade marshmallow fluff in a pastry piping bag.
Contains: Dairy, Egg
Pan-African Rainbow Cookies
Seasonal in February
Miniature rainbow cookies that include almond extract and raspberry jam in the Pan African colors symbolizing the blood shed in the fight for liberation (red), the people of the African diaspora (black), and the rich land and hope for the future (green).
Ice Cream Cakes
Chocolate Cake W/ Vanilla
6” Cake • Year-Round
Rich chocolate cake paired with premium vanilla ice cream
Red Velvet Cake with Blueberry Cheesecake
6” Cake • Year-Round
Layers of moist, crimson red velvet cake meet our award-worthy blueberry cheesecake ice cream – a rich, creamy blend studded with real fruit swirls.
Blueberry Cheesecake
6" or 8” Cake • Year-Round
Our super rich and very popular blueberry cheesecake ice cream into a 6” ice cream-based blueberry cheesecake!
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten
Carrot Cake Ice Cream Cake
6” Cake • Seasonal
A delicious pairing of carrot cake ice cream with carrot cake topped with a cream cheese frosting.
Contains: Dairy, Egg, Gluten, Nuts